The Amherst Board of Health in Massachusetts convened on Thursday to deliberate potential changes to existing nicotine and tobacco regulations, focusing on the sale of nicotine pouches.

This initiative aligns with actions taken by nearby communities aiming to tighten control over these products.

In February, the Board hosted a public forum to gather community insights on both sides of the issue. Thursday’s meeting continued this dialogue, reflecting on the feedback received.

Director Kiko Malin highlighted that the primary consideration is whether to restrict the sale of nicotine pouches to Amherst’s sole adult-only tobacco retail outlet. Such a measure would prohibit their availability in other retail or convenience stores within the town.

Malin noted that some community members advocate for stricter regulations due to Amherst’s significant youth population, stating, “Some people say it seems like it could be very important to restrict nicotine in Amherst because there are so many young people here.”

Conversely, concerns have been raised that limiting access to nicotine pouches might inadvertently drive individuals back to more harmful tobacco products. Nicotine pouches are often viewed as a less harmful alternative to smoking, and restricting their availability could lead users to revert to traditional cigarettes, which carry higher health risks.

The Board has not yet reached a decision. It plans to incorporate tobacco-free generation regulations into the proposed revisions and will schedule another public hearing to further discuss these matters.

The situation in Amherst mirrors broader debates on nicotine pouch regulations. For instance, New York legislators have proposed banning flavored nicotine pouches like Zyn, citing concerns over youth appeal.

However, critics argue that such bans could push users toward more harmful tobacco products, harm local businesses, and fuel black-market activities. They emphasize enforcing existing regulations rather than imposing new bans.