By Timothy S. Donahue

Top Takeaways:

  • Mounting Costs: Provisional liquidators and their advisers have incurred more than $54 million in fees and expenses since January, including $24.41 million for U.S. legal counsel.
  • Legal Challenge: Attorneys are seeking to terminate the liquidators’ U.S. powers after a British Virgin Islands court announced that the underlying liquidation applications should be dismissed.
  • Cigar Holdings: The dispute continues to cloud the future of Chen’s indirect interests in Habanos, Tabacalera and other international cigar businesses.

The liquidators may be on their way out, but they’re leaving behind a massive bill.

The international legal battle over businessman Chen Zhi’s corporate holdings, including significant interests in the premium cigar industry, has taken another turn as attorneys seek to curtail the powers of court-appointed liquidators, whose fees and expenses now exceed $54 million.

In documents filed on November 16 in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York, Cosimo Borrelli and the law firm Boies Schiller Flexner (BSF) renewed their request to terminate the automatic and discretionary relief granted to the joint provisional liquidators (JPLs) overseeing companies linked to Chen.

Borrelli identifies himself as the sole director of 25 of the British Virgin Islands (BVI) companies involved in the Chapter 15 bankruptcy proceedings, though his authority to act on their behalf has been contested.

The latest filings reveal the financial scale of the international liquidation effort and accuse the liquidators of continuing to incur unnecessary expenses despite the BVI High Court’s October announcement that it should dismiss the underlying liquidation applications.

“The fees are astronomical,” Borrelli’s attorneys wrote.

According to a November 11 application submitted by the liquidators in the BVI and quoted in the U.S. filing, “The JPLs and their advisors have incurred costs and expenses of approximately US$54,259,406.92 for the period from 9 January 2026 to 31 October 2026 . . . , which figure will necessarily increase.”

A separate affidavit from the provisional liquidator, James Kenneth Drury, also dated November 11, put the total at approximately $54.54 million for the same period.

According to the filing, the liquidators’ U.S. legal counsel, Sullivan & Cromwell, alone incurred $24.41 million in fees and disbursements through September 30—about $2.8 million per month.

The liquidators are seeking directions from the BVI court on approving their remuneration and expenses, including legal costs incurred in multiple jurisdictions, and on allocating those costs against the assets of one or more of the companies.

According to the November 16 filing, they are also seeking an order making their discharge conditional on payment of their fees and allowing them to continue incurring expenses until their discharge.

The $54 million figure, however, is far from a settled bill. The fees and expenses remain subject to BVI court approval, and the court could reduce or disallow amounts it finds excessive, unreasonable, or unjustified.

“It is past time to put a stop to the JPLs’ accumulation of fees and costs,” Borrelli’s attorneys wrote.

The attorneys contend that the liquidators no longer need the investigative powers granted under the U.S. recognition order, arguing that the 25 companies Borrelli claims to direct have neither assets nor operations in the United States.

“The Borrelli Debtors have no U.S. operations and no U.S. assets; there is nothing to transfer,” the attorneys wrote.

The liquidators, however, maintain that the existing BVI orders remain in effect and that they are “obliged to carry out their duties as court-appointed officeholders,” as stated in their opposition, which the November 16 filing quoted.

They have also argued that the U.S. recognition order “protects the Debtors’ U.S. property” and that removing their authority could “invite competing assertions of authority over the same companies.”

The dispute follows a significant development previously reported by Nicotine Insider.

On October 21, BVI High Court Justice Gerhard Wallbank ruled that the attorney general’s applications to liquidate the companies should be dismissed because the government failed to present sufficient admissible evidence.

However, the announcement did not immediately remove the provisional liquidators or restore the companies’ directors’ control. Those arrangements remained subject to further court proceedings.

According to the latest U.S. filing, Wallbank emphasized the “orderly implementation” of his October 21 decision and warned the liquidators of the risks of continuing their activities without seeking the court’s guidance.

Borrelli’s attorneys argue that the liquidators’ remaining responsibilities do not require ongoing investigative authority in the United States. “In short, since the JPLs will not agree to stand down in the United States, this Court should make them do so,” they wrote.

The attorneys also emphasized that terminating the liquidators’ U.S. powers would not immediately restore control of the companies to Chen. Borrelli has indicated that he will not assume control until the liquidators are formally discharged in the BVI.

The dispute has significant implications for the international premium cigar industry.

Among the 25 companies Borrelli claims to direct is Simply Advanced Limited, a holding company linked to Chen’s indirect interests in Allied Cigar Corporation and in approximately 28.55% of Cuba’s Habanos S.A., the state-controlled arm of the country’s cigar distribution network.

The broader cigar holdings include Spain-based Tabacalera, non-Cuban premium cigar manufacturing operations, and interests in international cigar-distribution businesses.

Chen was indicted by U.S. authorities in October 2025 on charges of wire fraud conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy related to alleged criminal operations in Cambodia. Separate civil forfeiture proceedings seek approximately 127,271 bitcoins.

Chen and the Prince Group have denied the criminal allegations. In a previous statement to NI, a spokesperson for the Prince Group of companies described the U.S. indictment and forfeiture complaint as “flawed and riddled with obvious errors.”

Neither the BVI court’s October announcement nor the latest New York bankruptcy filings resolves the criminal allegations, forfeiture proceedings, or international sanctions against Chen.

Borrelli has also appealed the original U.S. recognition decision, and his reply deadline has been extended to January 4, 2027, to allow the BVI court time to issue its decision.

His attorneys are asking the bankruptcy court to terminate the liquidators’ U.S. powers while the appeal remains pending, arguing that the requested relief addresses changed circumstances rather than the original recognition decision.

At issue now is not only when the liquidators will relinquish control of the companies, but also how much of the companies’ assets will ultimately be used to pay for their work. The $54 million bill has yet to receive final court approval.

Trending